Foreign banks and asset managers urge China to loosen data export controls. Will China listen or prioritize national security?
 |
| China's balancing act can the country ensure data security while remaining integrated with the global financial market. |
Beijing, June 20, 2024:
China's recent efforts to regulate data security have created a conundrum for the country's financial sector. While the government prioritizes protecting sensitive information, stricter data export restrictions are causing friction with foreign companies. This has led to calls from prominent financial institutions like Neuberger Berman and Citi for China to further ease these restrictions.
The Friction Caused by Data Silos
The crux of the issue lies in limitations on transferring data generated within China. Foreign banks and asset managers, accustomed to seamless cross-border information flow, are now facing hurdles. Research reports and portfolio data, crucial for internal operations and attracting foreign investors, are currently restricted.
Neuberger Berman, for instance, manages a mutual fund unit in Shanghai. However, data on their assets under management (AUM) cannot be freely transferred offshore. This makes it difficult for them to effectively manage internal operations and for investors to properly evaluate their strategies. Andrew Komaroff, Chief Operating Officer of Neuberger Berman Group, emphasizes the importance of data sharing for "global teams across the world to benefit from mutual insights."
Streamlining the Regulatory Landscape
Financial institutions are also advocating for a more streamlined approach to data classification and security reviews. Currently, China's data regulations, enacted in 2022, require all "important" data transfers to undergo a security assessment by the Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC). This not only creates delays but also leads to confusion, as Marc Luet, head of Banking at Citi for the Japan, Asia North & Australia Cluster, points out. "Dealing with multiple frameworks is always more difficult, because it leads to interpretation questions," he said.
The Shanghai Pilot: A Glimpse into the Future?
The recent pilot program launched in Shanghai offers a glimmer of hope. Companies registered in the city's Lingang Area can now transfer "ordinary data" overseas without security assessments. This initiative demonstrates China's willingness to experiment with more relaxed regulations in designated zones. However, the question remains: will this be the exception or the beginning of a broader reform?
The Global Landscape and Potential Repercussions
China's data export restrictions aren't happening in a vacuum. The global financial sector thrives on cross-border collaboration and information exchange. Stringent data control measures may hinder China's ability to attract and retain foreign investment. Additionally, it could limit the participation of Chinese financial institutions in global markets.
This isn't the first time concerns have been raised. In 2023, Fidelity International, another major investment firm, lobbied for relaxed data security rules in China. These repeated calls from prominent institutions highlight the potential roadblocks that China's data export restrictions may create for its continued economic integration with the global market.
Finding the Equilibrium
China faces a delicate balancing act. Ensuring data security is a legitimate concern, but overly restrictive policies can stifle innovation and hinder international collaboration. The path forward likely lies in finding an equilibrium – one that safeguards sensitive data while allowing for a more open flow of non-sensitive information crucial for a globally integrated financial sector.
Observing how the Shanghai pilot program unfolds and how Chinese authorities respond to the continued pressure from international financial institutions will be key indicators of China's future approach to data security and its implications for global economic integration.